You must log in or register to comment.
I have never understood the goal of passkeys. Skipping 2FA seems like a security issue and storing passkeys in my password manager is like storing 2FA keys on it: the whole point is that I should check on 2 devices, and my phone is probably the most secure of them all.
I love storing 2FA in the password manager, and I use a separate 2FA to unlock the password manager
I imagine you keep your password manager unlocked, or as not requiring 2FA on trusted devices then? Re entering 2FA each session is annoying
You still have the treat of viruses or similar. If someone gets access on your device while the password manager is unlocked (ex: some trojan on your computer), you’re completely cooked. If anything it makes it worse than not having 2FA at all.
If you can access your password manager without using 2FA on your phone and have the built in phone biometrics to open it like phone pin, finger or face, someone stealing your phone can do some damage. (Well, the same stands for a regular 2FA app, but meh, I just don’t see an improvement)
You’re right if I get a virus I’m pretty cooked. Except I think to set 2fa up on the attacker’s device they’d need the phone authenticator to set it up the first time, so hopefully they couldn’t do it unless they used my computer remotely to login to websites.
But the password manager locks after 15 min and you have to put a pin in to unlock and decrypt.
I’m not sure what brute force mechanisms it has against the pin.
Re-entering the 2fa each session is annoying but it’s way better than having to do it on each individual site from my phone.
The problem with PassKey is simply that they made it way more complicated.
Anyone who has worked with SSH keys knows how this should work, but instead companies like Google wanted to ensure they had control of the process so they proceeded to make it 50x more complicated and require a network connection. I mean, ok, but I’m not going to do that lmao.
Would love for you to describe exactly how it’s more complicated. From my perspective I click a single button and it’s set up. To log in I get a notification on my device, I click a button and I’m logged in.
Would love for you to describe exactly how it’s more complicated.
YOU JUST DID, below
From my perspective
neat.
I click a single button
… on your device tethered to a single app by a single vendor and their closed data store
and it’s set up.
… and tethered to prevent you from churning.
To log in I
… wait online to …
get a notification on my device,
… or send it again. Or again. Try again. Maybe mail it?
I click a button and I’m logged in.
Yeah. Just click (tap) a button (enter a code).
Using a big-brand MFA setup at one job that requires ‘one button’ and ‘get a notification’ and ‘click a button’, I know you’re glossing over the network issues HEAV-I-LY.
Now do it in airplane mode. Do it when the token organization is offline. Do it when there’s no power because the hurricane hit and there’s no cell, no data, no phones, and your DC is on its last hour of battery and you have to log in because the failover didn’t run.
Do it when your phone fell on its face in the rain into a puddle and it’s not nokia.
Do it when you either have cell service and 5% battery, or 100% battery from inside the DC and no cell service.
Do it when you’re tired, hungry, drunk, lost your glasses in the car accident.
The D in DR means DISASTER. Consider it.
For somebody complaining about making things complicated you certainly complicated the s*** out of a short post.
Storing your passkey in any of the shared password managers solves almost every problem you’ve listed.
With bitwarden and I have offline access to my passkey. I don’t know why the hell you’d need offline access to your pass key because they’re designed to protect online systems, But it could if I wanted it to.
With Bitwarden I can use my phone, or I can use my browser, or any one of four other browsers, or any other computer.
If I need to reset one of my pass keys I reset it in one place and it gets reset everywhere.
